Most small renal masses have a slow growth rate less than 3mmyear and a low risk of metastasis 4. Healthdayrenal mass biopsy is accurate for small renal masses 4 cm or less, according to a study published in the march issue of the journal of urology. Renal masses are a biologically heterogeneous group of tumors, ranging from benign masses, to indolent cancers that behave in a benign fashion, and finally, extremely aggressive and deadly cancers. The incidence of small renal masses srm has been increasing, and this is mainly attributed to the incidental finding of such masses on imaging performed in asymptomatic patients. Pdf despite the rise of small renal tumour srms diagnosis and related surgeries, death rate of kidney cancer is increasing, suggesting a. Healthdayamong patients who opt for active surveillance of small renal masses, growth rates are highly variable early on and do not reliably predict adverse outcomes, according to a study. Objectives to evaluate variables that can predict synchronous metastasis in patients presenting with small renal masses. A study from mayo clinic published in the october 2018 issue of european urology may help improve the effectiveness of patient counseling, affording patients the opportunity to make a more personalized. To discriminate between benign and malignant small renal mass to characterize of small renal mass for optimal treatment plans background detection of the small renal mass has increased with frequent utilization of imaging.
Recently, multiphasic helical ct has increased conspicuity for detection and characterization of small renal masses. What is a renal mass and what is a localized renal tumor. Many of these srms present in elderly patients with abnormal baseline renal function. Many small renal masses grow very slowly and have a low potential to spread to other. Small renal masses vary in biologic aggressiveness recent large surgical series indicate that up to 20% of small renal masses are benign, 55% to 60% are indolent renal cell carcinomas, and only 20% to 25% have potentially aggressive features, defined by high nuclear grade or locally invasive characteristics. Renal tumors are incidentally discovered at an increasing frequency due to the widespread use of crosssectional imaging. The role of biopsy is contentious, however clear reasons to biopsy a renal mass include a single functional kidney, bilateral or multiple tumours, prior to ablative therapy, chronic renal impairment and known other primary cancers to rule out metastasis. Aua guideline focuses on the evaluation and management of clinically localized renal masses suspicious for renal cell carcinoma rcc. The assessment must exclude metastases, in which case the patient would be considered to.
A prospective analysis from the renal cell carcinoma. Autopsy studies have demonstrated a prevalence of almost 50%. The natural history of small renal masses medscape. Opponents of premanagement biopsy of small renal masses are not difficult to find. They vary widely in biological aggressiveness, ranging from benign tumors to high grade renal cell carcinomas rccs. This results in management dilemma because at histopathology significant numbers of small renal masses are either benign tumors such as angiomyolipoma aml or oncocytoma, or are neoplasms with relatively indolent behavior. Canadian guidelines for the management of small renal. Mar 02, 2016 pathological renal masses renal cysts serous renal cyst. The natural history of small renal masses the safety and scientific validity of this study is the responsibility of the study sponsor and investigators. Small renal mass guidelines grand rounds in urology.
Renal tumor biopsy rtb for pretreatment identification of the pathology of small renal masses srms is safe and reliable and decreases unnecessary treatment. Imaging techniques are essential in the followup of these lesions. Initial active surveillance as is a reasonable treatment option for small renal masses. An observed stage migration is contributing to the increased detection of srm s.
Management of renal masses and localized renal cancer. Small renal masses are defined as renal masses less than 4. Nov 30, 2012 an increasing number of small renal masses srms are being detected with modern crosssectional imaging. Most renal tumors are now incidentally detected as small masses in asymptomatic. Diagnosis, patient counseling, and renal biopsy are covered in addition to various management strategies, including partial and radical nephrectomy, thermal ablation, and active surveillance. The assessment must exclude metastases, in which case the patient. Initial active surveillance as is a reasonable treatment option for small renal masses srms renal masses suspicious for renal cell carcinoma rcc in adults, including solid enhancing renal tumors and bosniak 3 and 4 complex cystic renal masses.
Listing a study does not mean it has been evaluated by the u. If a kidney lesion is a solid mass, particularly one that picks up blood and thus enhances on contrast ct, it is considered malignant until proven otherwise. Purpose to provide recommendations for the management options for patients with small renal masses srms. A renal mass discovered by routine ultrasound, ct or mr indicated for other pathology, could be named incidental. The true incidence of renal masses including benign lesions is unknown, but benign lesions comprise approximately 20% of surgically resected tumors. The role of nephrologists in the management of small renal masses. Some patients with clinically localized renal masses may present with findings suggesting aggressive tumor biology or may be upstaged on. Tony nimeh, urology research physician at brigham and womens hospital, harvard medical school. A chest xray is sufficient to look for lung metastases in small renal masses. The increase in the detection of small renal masses srms and their best knowledge leads to a change in the therapeutic management of these lesions.
Patients selected for ablation of small renal masses are older and have more comorbidities compared with those undergoing partial nephrectomy. Hu, md, and anthony chang, md division of kidney disease and hypertension, warren alpert medical school of brown university, rhode island. Pitfalls in renal mass evaluation and how to avoid them. Kidney function outcomes following thermal ablation of small. Between 1983 and 2002, the incidence of renal tumours 24 cm in diameter more than tripled to 3. The development of new imaging methods and advancements in techniques have aided in the detection, evaluation, monitoring of growth through active surveillance, treatment planning, and assessment of treatment response for these tumors. The fate of small renal masses, less then 1 cm size scielo. Partial nephrectomy yields lower allcause mortality, which is probably biased by patient selection and does not translate into prolonged cancerfree survival. Role of active surveillance of small renal masses 75 years the diagnosis of renal masses is increasing especially in the elderly population. Routine rtb should be considered in all patients with an indeterminate srm for which treatment is being considered. The standard of care for small localized renal neoplasms is partial or radical nephrectomy.
This article outlines a diagnostic and management approach to the incidental finding of a small renal mass or cyst. A search of these patients records revealed 1082 subsequent new cts for non uro. Initial tumor size defined as the maximal diameter was the most common baseline characteristics used to predict the growth rate of srms. Renal tumor biopsy rtb for the characterization of small renal masses srms has not been widely adopted despite reported safety and accuracy. Renal mass biopsy for the small renal mass sciencedirect. The greatest incidence of asymptomatic small renal masses occurs in elderly patients with multiple. This is the commonest form of cystic disease and is seen with increasing frequency with advancing age. Intravenous urography ivu is a relatively insensitive method for detecting renal masses, particularly if they occur centrally rather than peripherally. Therefore, as the vast major ity of these patients are cured of their kidney cancer, the maintenance of renal function is becoming the major determinant of clinical. Krokidis et al cirse guidelines on percutaneous ablation of small renal cell carcinoma 123. An increasing number of small renal masses srms are being detected with modern crosssectional imaging. The majority of small kidney growths are benign, while larger ones are more likely to be.
With increasing use of imaging to diagnose other conditions, incidentally detected small renal masses and cysts are now a common clinical scenario for both the general practitioner and the urologist. The natural history of small renal masses full text view. Thorough and informative patient counseling is paramount in the management of small renal masses srms, masses that are. Small renal masses srms, as a clinical entitiy, are defined as enhancing. A 65yearold man with a history of wellcontrolled hypertension presents for a followup visit after an incidental finding of a small mass in the right kidney on an abdominal computed tomographic. Not all patients with small renal masses require a biopsy. Modern management of small renal masses urology news.
Asco expert perspective while other major urologic and oncologic societies have published guidelines on kidney cancer over the past few years, this asco guideline is the first to uniquely focus on small renal masses. A renal mass can be broadly divided into two broad categories. Small renal masses srms can be approached with nephronsparing surgery, radical nephrectomy, tumor ablation, or active surveillance depending on tumor features, patient characteristics, and patient preferences. Indeed, as many as 25% of small renal masses srms are benign tumors. Cirse guidelines on percutaneous ablation of small renal cell. May 05, 2015 the natural history of small renal masses is not completely understood. A retrospective search for incidentally discovered small renal masses, less then 1 cm in size, was carried out in the files of 6 major us medical centers. The small renal masses guidelines pocket guide is based on the latest guidelines of the american society of clinical oncology and was developed with their collaboration. Renal cancer is the eighth most common cancer in the uk and accounts for about 3% of all new cancer diagnoses 1. Promoted articles advertising edit article share article. Natural history and management of small renal masses.
Renal masses benign and malign can be considered incidental if they are diagnosed in the absence of symptoms or signs. Patients with a localized renal mass should have a urologist involved with their care. The use of a less aggressive surgical technique or even an expectant attitude is the current tendency, in order to preserve as much renal function as possible. Emre huri tr in his lecture on as in small renal masses. The incidence of renal cell carcinoma is increasing, in part due to the growing use of crosssectional imaging.
Pitfalls in interpretation and diagnosing of small renal. Ct and mri of small renal masses the british journal of. American cancer society, american society for colposcopy and cervical pathology, and american society for clinical pathology screening guidelines for the prevention and early detection of cervical cancer. The nccn guidelines panel for cervical cancer screening endorses the following guidelines for the prevention and early detection of cervical cancer. However, the correlation between initial tumor size and growth rate is unclear. Hu, md, and anthony chang, md division of kidney disease and hypertension, warren. Defintion of small renal mass small renal masses srms, as a clinical entitiy, are defined as enhancing tumours renal cell carcinoma rcc. Partial nephrectomy versus ablative techniques for small.
Now, if a mass is small, less than 2 cm, up to 2025% of such lesions may be benign. All patients underwent ultrasound, rmi and multiphasic ct study. The cysts are frequently multiple and occur in various sizes. Many urologists contend that the benefits of biopsy do not outweigh the risks, arguing that the results do not influence management substantially and that the most useful information from renal mass biopsy can be attained with advanced imaging. Without pretreatment biopsy, patients with benign tumors are frequently overtreated. Renal biopsy is mandatory for every small renal mass. The major question to be answered is whether the mass represents a surgical or nonsurgical lesion or, in some cases, if followup studies are necessary. It is helpful in predicting a risk of malignancy and suggesting either follow up or treatment. The percutaneous method is better for some small renal masses because the procedure time is shorter, recovery is quicker and there is less need for pain medication. Jan 01, 2017 with technological advances and widespread use of imaging techniques such as ct and mri, renal masses are being diagnosed at much earlier stages in asymptomatic patients. Canadian guidelines for the management of small renal masses. Currently, there are no specific tumor markers to determine initial risk or progression to metastatic disease. Although most lesions are discovered on a sonographic examination, contrastenhanced ct remains the standard for the diagnosis of small renal cell carcinoma because of its cost, its ready availability, and its image quality.
Active surveillance for small renal masses a dramatic rise in the use of ct scans and mris over the last 20 years has resulted in the incidental diagnosis of thousands of small kidney renal masses. Louis kavoussi, the waldbaumgardiner chairman of the smith institute for urology at the north shorelij health system and professor at hofstra school of medicine, discusses the management of small renal masses in this interview with dr. Growth rate of small renal masses slow, 24 mmyear growth rate equal for benign oncocytoma and malignant masses. Non surgical management is a reasonable option in elderly and comorbid patients with limited life expectancy and increased perioperative risk. The incidence rates are steadily rising, with the highest rates being in older men and women. This rise is largely due to the increasing detection of incidental small renal masses. Schostak and others published treatment of small renal masses find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Evaluating renal masses1 with modern computed tomography ct and magnetic resonance mr imaging equipment, the diagnosis of most renal masses is usually straightforward and accurate. Such patients are at risk for further decline following therapeutic intervention. To analyze and characterize renal masses in order to avoid misunderstandings with the different imaging methods and mistaking in diagnosis. Solid renal masses malignant masses larger size is associated with higher grade. All of them can be categorized as benign, which means noncancerous, precancerous, which means that it may eventually cause cancer, and malignant, or cancerous. For any such mass, one of three conclusions can be drawn.
Epidemiological studies indicate that srms account for nearly onehalf of all newly diagnosed renal masses, largely based on incidental diagnosis during abdominal imaging. Small renal masses are increasingly diagnosed incidentally. Renal cell carcinoma represent 23% of all cancers and more than 50% of these are detected incidentally. The increasing use of crosssectional imaging has led to an increase in the diagnosis of incidental small renal masses srms. Workup and management of small renal masses susie l. The growth rate of a small renal mass on serial imaging however has not been shown to provide reliable prediction of malignancy or benignity. Small renal masses are benign approximately 2030% of the time 2. Bosniak classification system of renal cystic masses. There are many different types of kidney masses, ranging from cysts to adenomas to fibromas. Small renal masses diagnosis and management urology news. The fate of small renal masses, less then 1 cm size. In the era of ct scan however, masses are found at a much smaller size than ever before. Small renal masses are often detected as incidental find ings in older patients, typically among those aged at least 65 years.
The bosniak classification system of renal cystic masses divides renal cystic masses into five categories based on imaging characteristics on contrastenhanced ct. The first question for the radiologist is, which ones are cancer. Renal cell carcinoma rcc is the most common malignancy seen in the nephrology clinic, yet most nephrologists have inadequate knowledge of current treatment options. Rapn for small renal masses offers a safe alternative for patients 70 years of age, with no increase in. Most renal tumors are now incidentally detected as small masses in. Growth rates of small renal masses highly variable early on. It also helps to preserve renal function and spare the kidney. In renal masses of 12 cm which were surgically removed, 56% had a benign histology. Cirse guidelines on percutaneous ablation of small renal. About 20% of such masses are benign, while a significant proportion of malignant srms demonstrate slow growth kinetics and nonaggressive histologic features. It contains graded recommendations for diagnosis and treatment of small renal masses including a management algorithm.
Guideline for management of the clinical stage 1 renal mass. Small renal masses srm s are defined as cortical renal masses smaller than 4 cm in diameter. The likelihood of benignity is inversely related to size. A significant number of srms are incidentally diagnosed 2, 12. The diagnosis of small renal masses srms continues to increase likely attributable to widespread use of axial crosssectional imaging.
764 794 24 634 412 1037 631 251 35 651 1536 72 1294 586 1383 1100 1519 98 1303 172 783 500 110 1516 1068 1224 1084 656 1472 446 307 958 1286 575 995 28 127 864 1386 1241 230 300 583 1272 391 664 3 227 1417